ACLU
Video introduction to ProCon.org and the pros and cons of controversial topics
Last updated on: 3/12/2014 7:50:40 AM PST

Is the ACLU Good for America?

What do you think? Share your pro or con views and help us foster civil, intelligent discussion on important social issues. If you're looking to attack, harass, demean, or impersonate others, please go elsewhere. Read the rules on submitting comments at ProCon.org. Please note that the pro and con comments and thumbs up/down votes reflect the views of ProCon.org readers and not necessarily of ProCon.org or society in general. Remember to enter your email address so we can notify you if your comment gets posted. Thank you!

PRO (yes) Comments (12)

1,250 characters left

Notify me by email when someone replies to my comments
Also sign up for our free e-newsletters

Sort by: Best | Newest | Oldest

  • +15 +32 -17 Tara Apr. 28, 2011
    "The great thing about the ACLU is that they will fight for your constitutional rights whether or not you like them -- and whether or not they like you. What they defend is not one position or another, but the rights we are all guaranteed under the constitution. If we save the freedom of speech for those speakers we agree with... who decides who gets to speak?"
    1250 characters left
    • +1 +5 -4 William Nov. 16, 2011
      "Not true."
    • 0 +5 -5 Keith Jan. 2, 2012
      "Show me one case where they have defended my right to carry a firearm or a right for a life to continue un-aborted. They wont even defend your precious right to free speech. Where was the ACLU when High School students were being punished for wearing the American Flag on a t-shirt?"
  • +10 +27 -17 Teri Apr. 28, 2011
    "This country is not now and was designed NEVER to be a theocracy. If your desire is for religion to be the core of our government you are forever destined to be disappointed. The ACLU staunchly defends the unambiguous constitutional separation of church and state. We are ALL safer because of this. Those who whine the loudest would be stunned to know how very much safer they REALLY are due to this protection. What if someone ELSE's god claims superiority and wants to rule the nation? Fighting because 'god is on our side' has decimated many a civilization. Keeping the gods in their places is a very sophisticated concept; elegant in its simplicity and universal value. Thank you founders and thank you ACLU!!"
    1250 characters left
    • -1 0 -1 Jerry Blanque Feb. 9, 2012
      ""someone" - you can find the separation of church and state in the 1st amendment.

      There is no text about the right to free speech excluding yelling "fire" in a crowded theater, yet such an act is actually not protected speech (Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969))."
    • -1 +1 -2 somone Feb. 3, 2012
      "separation of church in state is no where in the constitution. it was in a letter by Jefferson to the Church that said that government would not interfere with the church."
  • +5 +22 -17 A retired soldier Apr. 28, 2011
    "I am amazed at the amount of hate that can be generated simply by a lack of complete information or uncontained passion. The issues at hand should not be decided in the throes of heated emotionalism. Many people who 'hate' the ACLU for what it does are closet bigots. Essentially what they are espousing is due process and equal rights for every person who is like them, but if someone is different, then their rights go out the window.... The ACLU approaches the Constitution pragmatically and UNEMOTIONALLY. The Bill of Rights are the same rights for every American, regardless of race, religion, sex, and as disgusting as it seems - criminal charge."
    1250 characters left
  • +3 +4 -1 Lewis Dec. 1, 2013
    "I am seeing a lot of negative statements about the ACLU and nothing to really back those statements up. And frankly, some of the anti ACLU comments sound absolutely nutty!! These people are the reason we need the ACLU in the first place. There are people who would love to see their religion shoved upon everyone. They complain about god being taken out of everything when it shouldn't have been there to begin with. They act as if they're victims because they're not being allowed to impede upon other people's lives with their religion. I'm glad we have the ACLU to fight for the separation of church and state."
    1250 characters left
  • +3 +16 -13 Brock Sep. 2, 2011
    "The ACLU has defended conservatives and liberals, religious leaders and athiests, Nazis and Jews - basically they don't care who you are. They defend the Constitution and Bill of Rights.

    People who oppose the ACLU don't understand the organization. Everyone should appreciate what the ACLU does and has done for the country.

    To oppose them is unpatriotic because you're saying you oppose the Constitution."
    1250 characters left
  • +2 +6 -4 David Nov. 23, 2012
    "Bill of Rights is by its nature unpopular - protecting minority against majority. ACLU has recognized this from their beginning and advocates nonetheless, or perhaps because. ACLU, at its best, exercises the sort of discomforting vigilance that is the price of liberty. We are fortunate to have them advocating as they do. Else we'd not long bother with those out of step with society's norms and inclined, or at least willing, to question authority."
    1250 characters left
  • +2 +12 -10 Jerry Blanque Feb. 10, 2012
    "The ACLU is vital to America. Speech that doesn't offend needs no protection; it is the stuff that makes our blood boil that needs to be allowed to be expressed.

    The ACLU doesn't defend the 2nd amendment and they even tell you why: http://www.aclu.org/organization-news-and-highlights/second-amendment

    Finally, the belief that the ACLU wants to take god out of (schools, public square, etc) is laughable. The ACLU is about respect for everyone's beliefs, just as the Founding Fathers were. EVERYONE IS ALLOWED to practice their own faith (or abstain for those who don't) as long as it isn't disruptive to others. A government entity (i.e., a public school) IS NOT ALLOWED TO PROMOTE a specific religion. That means no official school prayers, religious icons, or whatever.

    I would encourage anyone who wants to live in a Theocracy to "try before you buy" BEFORE they try to destroy our Democracy. There are lots of countries that have an official religion, whose laws are based upon said religious texts and who arrest/kill/force-convert non-believers. Go live in one for a few months and see if you find it to be the utopia you imagine."
    1250 characters left
    • 0 +1 -1 Mike Mopsick Jul. 23, 2012
      "So you are saying that the ACLU does not defend Christians because there is no violation of their rights ... ever?

      Maybe the ACLU does not offend you because your personal agenda aligns so neatly with theirs. You would think if they were non-partisan, the opinions of them would not follow so neatly only party lines. If you fail to see this, you aren't paying attention.

      None are so blind as those that will not see."
  • +1 +16 -15 G.P. Apr. 28, 2011
    "Wow...I knew the Christian Right didn't like the ACLU...I didn't realize how vitriolic their disdain could be! That said, I go on record as approving of the ACLU, for many reasons, but primarily because they uphold the rights of all citizens based ONLY on constitutionality."

    Your god is not necessarily my god, however, the Constitution unequivacably declares my right to worship, or not worship, as I choose. With that, I am allowed to practice my religion, or lack thereof, by whatever law-abiding manner I choose. So, if I want to erect a statue of Dick Cheney in my front yard, a la the Virgin Mary, I can do so; and, worship him at a public meeting by drinking beer and smoking cigars, I can do that, too. That doesn't make me an evil person, nor does it undermine anyone else's ability to live and/or worship as they choose. Haven't our forefathers fought these battles to ensure our freedoms to think and lawfully act as we choose?"
    1250 characters left
  • -1 +4 -5 me Jan. 24, 2013
    "ACLU are gone to do what they have been doing,which is whatever they want then get on public news in front of everyones face an say the total opposite :) good day"
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +5 -7 rachel fernny Nov. 15, 2012
    "the great thing about (aclu) is good because it shoes the right things to do..."
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +10 -12 The Liberalist Mar. 1, 2012
    "In the constitution states that every person in this country is equal why should we shun those who help protect that equality?
    What sense does it make to end an organization that supports our fore father's wishes and the rights of the american people?
    What sense does it make to end organizations that help those who suffer inequality? What kind of country are we to NoT support organizations that support the rights of the constitution?
    The United stars of America is a place where 2 men can hold hands... And not be shunned. Where 2 people can get married, when they're different races. Where people can be whoever they want to be and are free to do so.
    Keep America a free nation."
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +8 -10 Matthew Dec. 22, 2011
    "In a wash of media trying to destroy our government the ACLU has analyzed bills on how they will effect our country. They're documents on government violations on freedom for every country leaves nothing out for any of them. They defend our bill of rights and fight for everyone regardless of race, sex, creed, nationality, or other dividing factor. They are true Constitutionalists. As the far-right machine is attempting to stop people from voting the ACLU is fighting to protect our right to vote, our only defense against corporatocracy and oligarchy. It is the least hypocritical organization (except for the SPLC which ties with them) in the world. They may expose uncomfortable truths, which they do a lot, but that is necessary in defending our freedom. If it weren't for them there would be no successful defender for the bill of rights except for the SPLC. Plus, they are non-partisan and have spoken out against abuses from either side. Because of the ACLU, I am able to right this message."
    1250 characters left

CON (no) Comments (24)


1,250 characters left

Notify me by email when someone replies to my comments
Also sign up for our free e-newsletters

Sort by: Best | Newest | Oldest

  • +11 +32 -21 Victor Apr. 28, 2011
    "There is one simple question I would ask of the ACLU. If they have fought for the separation of church and state for these many decades, why have they not filed one single suit, or made one outcry over the use of tax payers money to install foot washing stations in Minnesota airports for Muslims? Where is their concern over the separation of church and state when it does not apply to Christians? The ACLU can pretend all it wants about being for civil liberties, it's all smoke and mirrors. The true goal of the ACLU is to remove Christian/Judean values and any notion of morality from the public square."
    1250 characters left
    • +3 +5 -2 Jerry Blanque Feb. 10, 2012
      "A few facts for your Michael Savage story:

      1) The facilities were added without using public funds (they were financed by cap fare increases for that specific purpose)

      2) The facilities are usable by anyone for any reason -- filling buckets, washing tools, whatever. They are not restricted to people who want to wash their feet for religious reasons.

      3) The facilities are not labelled as "Islamic" (unlike the "Chapel" that exists in most--if not all--airport terminals).

      4) There is no religious display, texts, or signs in the area. The entire facility is simply a few tiled seats in front of low faucets and a drains in the floor.

      If the ACLU was all about "removing" values and morality (wow--you'll have to explain how to do that), do you think they would go after the Chapels? Oh wait, they haven't."
    • 0 0 0 Chloe Feb. 26, 2014
      "They target other issues besides religion, you know. It just happens that people that are religious (particularly Christians) tend to disagree with them on those issues as well, and the use the card "You are just targeting out religion!" to force their opinions out of range. I also would like you to clarify what morality is; forcing the laws of your religious book onto everyone around you, or practicing them in your life?"
    • -1 +2 -3 C. A. Jan. 1, 2013
      "You are absolutely correct when you state the true goal of the ACLU. Kudos to you for standing up for what is right. I am with you all the way!! Take God out of the picture and you have an Atheist country. Oh wow, now isn't this something to be proud of as Americans who are supposed to have freedom of speech, but who actually have no say."
  • +9 +19 -10 Carl Jan. 30, 2012
    "If you go to the ACLU website and post a comment on an article, they monitor them in a way that if it is something they do not like, it does not get posted. How ironic is that? The organization that fights for our freedom of speech chooses what we are allowed to say on their website. hmm...."
    1250 characters left
    • 0 +1 -1 T.F. Ender Sep. 16, 2012
      "Yes their website not yours."
  • +7 +16 -9 Keith Jan. 2, 2012
    "The ACLU does not defend ALL rights. They have a history of only defending their own definition of "rights" and leave issues that would be considered "conservative" to twist in the wind. Thier high minded attitude does not represent an impartial defense of the constitution and the rights that it assures. The so called rights have been manufactured from whole cloth and extended to lenghts that are beyond the scope of thier purported mission."
    1250 characters left
  • +5 +22 -17 Ted May. 25, 2011
    "As AM Rosenthal of the New York Times once said, "The ACLU hides behind the term 'civil liberties' like a fascist hides behind the flag."

    The opposition will tell you that the ACLU will fight for "your rights." Rubbish. When was the last time you heard the ACLU defending gun owners, who clearly have a Constitutional right to their firearm. Enough said."
    1250 characters left
    • +4 +4 0 Paul Sep. 17, 2011
      "The ACLU defended texas gun owners in 2007, as reported by the New York Times. Enough said.

      http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/05/us/05guns.html"
  • +2 +8 -6 John Graham Oct. 18, 2012
    "In our society, we do not need any extremist organisations that answer to no one. The ACLU, unfortunately, despite its protests, is such an extremist organisation that the United States could well do without."
    1250 characters left
  • +2 +8 -6 Russell Van Brocklin May. 1, 2012
    "By protecting the rights of the minority the rights of the majority are compromised. Although this is a complicated statement the majorities opinion and rights need to reflect the opinion of the group they make up."
    1250 characters left
  • +2 +16 -14 Merlin Apr. 28, 2011
    "The ACLU is the most dangerous organization in America. They make safe havens for our most feared enemies. Criminals love the ACLU. They are not for the rights of the average American citizen. This organization should be abolished."
    1250 characters left
  • +1 +18 -17 Chris Jul. 28, 2011
    "I believe the ACLU is bad for America because they claim to champion civil liberties but they pick and choose which civil liberties to defend, an example being the right to an abortion. They choose not to respect life, a civil liberty, but instead to support another right in its place. For this reason, I feel that the ACLU should simply stay out of that issue or change their opinion. So long as they are involving themselves, they are dividing Americans."
    1250 characters left
    • +1 +3 -2 Jerry Blanque Feb. 10, 2012
      "In other words, if they don't defend every civil liberty then they should be disbanded.

      Hmm. Defending everything might cost a lot of coin. You want to write a check?"
  • 0 +13 -13 Ed, a Marine Mar. 4, 2012
    "Bad for America and its preservation. The ACLU has made socialism one of its main goals for our country.....and this is not an organization for America or "We The People".

    "In God We Trust".....beware of the ACLU."
    1250 characters left
  • 0 +12 -12 Daniel Feb. 17, 2012
    "Because they're radical liberal extremists who won't let us kill people who deserve to die. If they're all about freedom, let me say this to them: I'd like the freedom to not have to worry about getting murdered by someone that the ACLU set free by feeding us some rhetoric about how the death penalty is immoral. Also I think the unborn would like the freedom to have a life."
    1250 characters left
  • -1 +11 -12 Randy Jun. 9, 2011
    "I have seen some of the things that the ACLU has tried to do and I think that they are going too far in some of the things they are getting into."
    1250 characters left
    • +2 +3 -1 Paul Sep. 17, 2011
      "How about giving a specific example of a legal position they argued that you were against!"
  • -1 +15 -16 Kat Apr. 28, 2011
    "I think an organization who has socialism as a main goal for America is not an organization for America. It is opposed to the American beliefs. My people did not come to this country from England and Ireland to fight for this country to see it socialized. This is not the USSA-United Socialist State of America. It is the USA-United State of America."
    1250 characters left
  • -1 +15 -16 Ruby Apr. 28, 2011
    "When I heard in my US Government class about ACLU I was astonished. I couldn't believe that people in this country thought like this. They have no morals and are taking things a bit too far. They use big fancy words trying to makes it seem like what they think is a positive thing for the country when they're going to destroy us if we don't do something about it to stop it. I know it's freedom of speech but the ACLU is taking things to far. Especially with supporting pedophiles. How can people with common sense think these things are ok?

    I believe 'some' things they have done have benefited about country but they are going to far. As united Americans I don't think people will let this happen for very long, I know I'm not. If we let this go on who knows what kind of things they will try to support in 10 or 20 years. This is madness and I disagree with ACLU and hope anything they try to accomplish, fails."
    1250 characters left
  • -1 +16 -17 Anne Marie Apr. 28, 2011
    "I think the ACLU has done more damage to this country than I have seen in the 65 years I've been on this earth. They interfere with our justice system and, even though people are guilty, they manage to set them free. Pedophiles must love this organization. When I was growing up this country ran fine. What happened to make us need an organization like this?


    They want to have the cross ripped down from the desert. That cross wasn't bothering anybody and now the cross issue is in front of the Supreme Court. You have got to be kidding me! Sleazy lawyers are chomping at the bit for this job!! The ACLU should disbanded!"
    1250 characters left
  • -2 0 -2 Owen Calhoun Jan. 9, 2014
    "Is the ACLU good for America? Not if it takes away what Americans have had and lived by all of their lives. Their religious beliefs are being erased and they will be replaced by the religion of those coming into the country with their own form of religion which is not that of Americans. Remove the religion that Americans live by and it will get replaced by those who are not and never will be Americans. Protect Americans but not from themselves. Hang on to the beliefs of all Americans and protect Americans from those who would come here to change them to their way of thinking!"
    1250 characters left
  • -2 0 -2 John Morgan Oct. 16, 2013
    "Ref: Position 33 re:2 nd Amendment.The posted position is obsolete and thus untrue.Recent legal scholars published in law school journals,and the USSC, agree that the 2nd Amendment establishes an INDIVIDUAL RIGHT.,contrary to the long standing ACLU's collectivist policy."
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +4 -6 arrudac@twcny.rr.com Jan. 1, 2013
    "I will NEVER support the ACLU!!! Of course this comment will never get posted; I would be a fool to think otherwise, because I don't think like you nor do I brainwash people into thinking that it is OK to take GOD out of our life. Shame on you, may all who support the ACLU rot in hell for taking GOD out of the schools and work place. Whatever happened to freedom of speech. Morons have more rights than good and decent people do."
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +5 -7 Michael Sep. 17, 2012
    "It appears that the ACLU has the best interests of those that are not American Citizens at heart. They identify constitutional rights for those that are not bound by the consitiution. I'm trying to figure out why it would be so diffiucult to produce some sort of identification to vot in an American Election. What would be the harm. It would benefit those that are Americans by not catering to those that are not. Is something so wrtong with that? verification that a person has the right to vote. Isn't that a right of every American. Not sure that non-Americans have that right. No in fact I'm sure that Non-Americans do not possess the right to vote. So why is this such a bad idea? What American Right does it infringe upon?"
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +4 -6 David Michel Aug. 30, 2012
    "I recently tried to enlist the help of the ACLU because I was banned upon pain of arrest from Denver Public Library property for writing 2 e-mails aimed at getting the library to quit using the hackable and liberty endangering surveillance technology known as RFID. The dangers to liberty of this technology have been amply demonstrated by Katherine Albrecht in her books and websites. I did not do anything illegal in writing those letters. I did threaten to sue. It is legal to do so. I received a thugish and threatening phone call on the family voice-mail that everyone could hear and which was left by Denver Public Library security. I will be arrested if I even set foot on Denver Public Library property and I did nothing wrong or illegal. I made no threats of violence and used no profanity. I strongly and in a legal manner disagreed with library policy and attempted to change the policy. THE ACLU REFUSED TO DEFEND MY RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH!"
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +7 -9 Richard Clark May. 30, 2012
    "This country was founded on the Christian convictions of our fore-fathers. It seems the past goal of the ACLU was, as it should, for the people and by the people. Now, in this time of every man for himself, they have developed a change of heart. It seems that instead of pushing for americans freedoms and staying true to the constitution of the United States, they have closed many of the freedoms on account of offensiveness. It seems that we have become at the mercy of their choosing. I have hope, though, that they will return to their founding stance to defend the rights of everyone that is a partaker of this wonderful country."
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +11 -13 Gordon Jun. 11, 2011
    "Another Confused Lie Unfolds..."
    1250 characters left
  • -2 +21 -23 Pam Apr. 28, 2011
    "The ACLU is nothing but a bunch of communists whose goal is to destroy America and Christianity. They are on the same level as terrorists. Separation of church and state was formed so that a government could not dictate one specific religion to it's people. The ACLU have twisted it's meaning and use every opportunity to destroy anything to do with God. They should join up with Bin Laden, or have they already?"
    1250 characters left
    • +3 +3 0 Marina Oct. 22, 2011
      "It is sad that people instead of talking to each other, I mean people with different point of view choose talk to the crowd that supports their opinions only. My choice of religion is none, and this choice is protected by the Constitution as well. I as an atheist may not want my child to recite every day: One nation under God. I am NOT a communist because of it. My references are different, that's all."
  • -2 +14 -16 Terri Apr. 28, 2011
    "There's not too many things in this world that I despise more than the ACLU. Critical thought by anyone with even a partial brain can see that the ACLU's mission is to topple this country of ours. The crumbling of the USA has begun thanks to this ignorant organization that somehow works to impose the beliefs of 5-10% of the population onto the entire society. The organization has been successful at making a mockery of the ideals of this country. While ACLU attorneys get rich, we all lose in the end. The ACLU should be ashamed of themselves and so should those that support its cause."
    1250 characters left
  • -3 0 -3 Court Jan. 24, 2013
    "Absolutely NOT,first off NSL(national security letters)is like taking candy from a baby.Allows FBI to obtain any sensitive personal records without court order?just as simple as requseted..

    Religion-GoD is Love An love is God, thats just another way to seperate the world,

    abortion-who made these laws up? someone who wants to see clash? someone bitter? is it someone who is angery? i mean who wants that much control over billions of lives? A weirdo that was not born yesterday"
    1250 characters left
Visit the ProCon.org community on:

© 2014 ProCon.org, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit     |   233 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 200, Santa Monica, CA 90401    |    Tel: 310-451-9596   




Hide/Show